Good pizza. Fast service. Friendly people. They have indoor and outdoor seating areas, too, with that great NYC pizza parlor ambiance, so this is a good option when you want to sit and mingle. They offer such fast service that it's also a great option when you just want to grab and go and eat a slice while you walk.

This place was pretty good. Would recommend. The food was great, the service wasn't slow, and it was nice.

Five stars. Impeccable service--we ordered by phone for pickup late last night around 11:30. They told us 15 minutes. We were a three minute walk--they had the pizza fresh and hot and perfectly cooked in 12 min. Perfect New York Style dough mix between a crispy, dark brown exterior and a nice little chew to the dough with bubbles on the crust. Delicious brightness to the tomato sauce and delectable cheese. Not overpriced and well seasoned. I expected to eat two slices and ended up eating six.

I'm obsessed with NY Slice Pizza! Not only did I enjoy their deliciously slices with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce, but I also received top-notch service! The staff were friendly, attentive, and made sure my experience was nothing short of fantastic. The pizza is truly exceptional - no flop, just a beautifully cooked crust. I'm so impressed with this NYC-style pizza joint, and I can't recommend it enough. The combination of mouthwatering pizza and excellent service.

This is the spot when you want a late night slice of pizza or even the whole pie ! We came here around 2pm and it was busy but the service was great, we got our pizza super fast and it was heated in the big oven. You must get the classic style with cheese and pepperoni! It was delicious! Definitely recommend!

10/10 Food was yum! We went around 10pm and to be almost closing time it was very busy. I'd definitely come back if i'm in the area.

Pretty fast service with delicious pizza! Be warned the pizza is extremely oily and heavy, but super yummy! Highly recommend the vodka as well as the spicy pepperoni.

This joint embodies what an out-of-towner like myself envisions a NYC pizza parlor should be. Big selection of pizzas by the slice served up quick and hot with a gruff but polite manager (who bears a resemblance to actor John Carroll Lynch) moving things along. The slices were the best we had on this trip--big and foldable with a hot crisp bottom. The real winner, however, was the eggplant Sicilian. Thick buttery crust with nice tender eggplant slices buttressed by mozzarella and a killer red sauce. If it were only hot in the middle, this would be a 5 star review. The dining room is small but serviceable and tables cleared pretty quickly with what appeared to be mostly locals dining there. A nice place to stop after an afternoon at the Museum of Natural History (a few blocks away). (4.5 stars).

Great grandma slices! The favorite today was the veggie with peppers, onions and mushrooms. The upside down was okay. Might have been better if we had eaten it right out of the oven. Tried the garlic knots (5 for $4). They very large, greasy, garlicky; overall good! NOTE: there is a service charge if you pay by credit card